Letter of the Law, Not the Spirit

Date:

Share post:

Goshen Pond on the Wharton tract. Photo: Jason Howell

Our columnist comments on how the Pinelands Commission handled cedar on the Wharton tract.

On October 9, the Pinelands Commission—the state body charged with protecting New Jersey’s million-acre Pinelands—voted to approve a plan to cut trees, and spray herbicide across 171 acres of Atlantic white cedar swamp in Wharton State Forest. How the Commission handled that decision deserves as much scrutiny as the plan itself. 

- Advertisement -

Atlantic white cedar swamps are an integral part of the Pinelands ecosystem, but its footprint shrunk from about 115,000 acres in New Jersey to roughly 25,000. The NJ Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) wants to restore it, which is a goal that Pinelands Alliance supports. However, several aspects of the written plan raised concerns that this might actually be more of a logging plan than restoration.

The application proposed removing 2,475 cords of cedar, which would amount to about 42 percent of the total harvest. A cord is the equivalent of anywhere from one to five trees depending upon the size of the tree. Loggers who showed up in support of the plan seemed to interpret this figure as a harvest quota—and why shouldn’t they? It’s written right there in the application.  

Meanwhile, concerned Commissioners and members of the public were being asked to rely on verbal testimony that this was not a timber cruise. Cutting cedar to save cedar is an awkward pitch. With only the written permit application to go off of, public commentaries on the plan were justified in their skepticism. 

A Worst-Case Permit and a Best-Case Presentation: On voting day, DEP staff gave a presentation to explain away many concerns about the application, which they described as a “worst case scenario.” What they actually intend, they said, is far more modest: Leave the big old trees, and treat the cord count as the high end of the estimate. That is useful information, but it arrived too late: on the day of the vote, after the record was supposed to be closed.

Since the permit described a worst case, getting the documents into the hands of the public earlier wouldn’t have helped. You can’t meaningfully comment on a document that doesn’t say what the agency actually plans to do. The only way to learn the real plan was to ask the applicant, and the only public forum where that happened was the meeting where the record was closed.

DEP deserves some credit here. Its staff acknowledged gaps and promised better applications for future rounds of cedar restoration. But the Pinelands Commission is the body that runs the review, and determines whether the public gets what it needs before the vote—not after. They don’t seem eager to improve their processes for next time.

Big decision, small process: The Commission knows how to do better. It regularly gives much smaller matters a public presentation months before a vote, followed by a dedicated hearing. Many of these hearings are attended by almost no one. For example, two hearings were held this year for housing elements in Manchester and Monroe Township, that each received zero public comments—and a third hearing was held for proposed amendments to the Pinelands Infrastructure Trust Fund, which garnered a single comment. 

Clearly, when the Pinelands Commission chooses to make room for the public, it can. For one of the most significant forestry applications in years, it chose not to.  This situation highlights the Pinelands Commission’s inconsistent administration of its own regulations.

Commissioner Mauriello said he hoped to have this kind of conversation “a little bit earlier in the process.” When both the applicant and the commissioners are saying the process should be more open, the agency running it has little excuse for defending the status quo.

What should change? The irony is that most of this conflict was completely avoidable. Everyone in the room agreed that Atlantic White Cedar restoration is a worthy goal. The real source of confusion was the gap between the written application and what the applicant actually intends to do—as explained through their presentation. What should have been a collaborative public process was turned into conflict by the Pinelands Commission’s public engagement policies. 

Eleven more units of cedar restoration are coming, and the Commission now knows what it looks like when the application and the intent don’t match. Next time, make sure the public is informed of that gap while it can still affect the outcome. The cedar has waited generations for restoration. It can wait a few more months for a process that lets the public scrutinize the real plan before the vote, not hear about it after.

Previous article

Current Issue

SNJ Today
SideRail

Related articles

Puff Pastry

Try this recipe for a holiday brunch—or anytime. If you’re gathering recipe ideas for the holidays, here’s a good...

East Point Lighthouse To Benefit From New Lease Agreement

New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection (NJDEP) Commissioner Ed Potosnk recently joined with state and local officials to...

Field Trip to a Museum

A bus trip to the Museum of the American Revolution proves to be a definitive lesson in patriotic...

New Jersey Legislative Update

Source: Greater Vineland Chamber of Commerce Advocacy Committee New Jersey employers face upcoming payroll adjustments, expanded leave protections  and...